Which is a better trade for a 12...

Which is a better trade for a 12-team SF rebuilding team losing Kamara?
Caveat: Are either enough?
Addendum: What would you trade for him if you were a contender?

Kamara/Wicks for late 1 and 2

Kamara for JJ Mccarthy

This voting is public, your choice will be displayed for others.

Comments (5)

· Corey FFAN

· 2024-09-24T23:53:50+0000
I don’t love either of them, honestly. I kind of feel like you can hang on to him a bit longer and a team that really wants to push for a championship will pay better.
But if it has to be one of these then I am going with the picks.

2
- · TexasTrojan2004
  
  · In reply to
  
  Corey FFAN
  
  · 2024-09-25T03:36:11+0000
  Problem is, Kamara is hurting my pick position, so it's rather trade him sooner than later
  
  2
· Kyle_FFAN

· 2024-09-25T04:20:10+0000
I'm with @Corey FFAN on this. Even if you know you want to trade him, you can do better than these if you're patient enough.

2
- · TexasTrojan2004
  
  · In reply to
  
  Kyle_FFAN
  
  · 2024-09-25T14:08:45+0000
  What would you expect in return?
  
  1
- · Kyle_FFAN
  
  · In reply to
  
  TexasTrojan2004
  
  · 2024-09-25T22:43:19+0000
  It's hard to know what to go for not seeing the other rosters, but that 1st and a player with a lot of upside I'd rather have than that 2nd. Someone like Roschon Johnson maybe, chase brown, etc. if you're wanting a RB. Lots of WRs fit that mold. If you want QB, I'd shoot for like a penix over McCarthy. Literally a million possibilities, just some that come to mind off the top of my head.
  
  1